Peanut Butter and Jelly
Dante: 3rd place, Me: Last place
This one just didn't have enough flavor for me, and the texture of the jelly wasn't meshing particularly well. That said, I think with just a couple modifications (more peanut butter, melting the jelly), it would be fantastic. Dante thought it was a really good combination of tastes and textures.
How we did it:
Peanut Butter and jelly (Jif and Strawberry Smuckers, of course) drizzled across the slice